TIMOR EAST
ANALISIS OF THE CONFLICT
(september 25th 1999)
Spetial points:
1] East Timor is "yesterday’s" focus; today’s is West Timor and the other islands where East Timorese have been deported and are now being intimidated and even murdered.
2] East Nusa Tenggara (West Timor, Flores and Sumba) have now been targeted as the next areas for destabilisation. This is where 35% of Indonesian Catholics live and the second biggest Protestant Church is (Evangelical Church of Timor). West Timor and Flores are being overrun with the army and is being systematically destabilised.
3] East Timor should not be seen as an isolated incident; it needs to be understood as part of the overall strategy of the Jakarta military elite to survive and prosper. Thus, it is utterly absurd to soft peddle East Timor to "assist" the "democratic" process in Jakarta.
4] We should remember the economic stake of "Soeharto Inc." in the western part of East Timor including oil (land and off-shore deposits), sandalwood, coffee and marble. A war has begun to regain this territory (8 districts) for Jakarta.
5] This is a carefully planned and thoroughly implemented genocide by the army. Wiranto is involved, and took part in planning sessions in Jakarta last August.
THE MILITARY PLAN FOR EAST TIMOR
Is still in operation and consists of four elements:
When the young seminarians (high school) were being led out of the Balide, Dili, seminary on 6-12 September, after a last minute reprieve form slaughter, and after receiving absolution (prayers for the dying) from a priest, they were taunted with the remark: "political elite". (Former seminarians have played an important part in all political parties and persuasions over the past 25 years.) Guns were held at their brows, and knives under their throats, as they were escorted to evacuation trucks. 1. Evacuate by force everybody in the 8 Districts in the western half of East Timor. A figure mentioned by the East Timor army commander Colonel Muis on Sept. 3rd before the vote announcement was 250,000 people to be deported.
The eight western Districts are 1. Oecusse, 2. Covalima (Suai), 3. Bobonaro (Maliana), 4. Liquica, 5. Ermera, 6. Aileu, 7. Ainaro, 8. Manufahi (Same).
The five Eastern districts are 1. Dili, 2. Manatuto, 3. Baucau, 4. Lautem (Los Palos), 5. Viqueque.
4. Trashing and scorched earth. This has, like the deportations, been outstandingly successful. The total obliteration of Dili and other towns prompted one observer to suggest that it will take 5 years to rebuild. The mass deportation of a quarter of a million people and the scorched earth policy have been outstandingly successful. Absolutely remarkable - all in just three weeks. (Sept. 5 - 25)
4. Genocide by smashing East Timorese national identity, historical ties with Portugal and Macau, he Catholic identity of both culture and people.
FIGHTING AGAINST THE UN
1. Indonesian aim:
The Military Plan is still in operation, but has had to be adapted to take into account the arrival of UN troops. Instead of an easy integration of the 8 western districts into Indonesia, now these districts must be fought for, and won back for Indonesia.
2. National Unity Front:
A meeting was held in Kupang on 19 or 20 September. The meeting was under the leadership of the TNI (Indonesian army) and all East Timorese militias attended. The result of the meeting was that a new, expanded and united Front has been formed, consisting of all the former militias. It is called "Front Persatuan Bangsa" (FPB) - National Unity Front.
The former militias (called PPI) have been merged into FPB and now no longer technically exist as separate entities. It is likely they still have local loyalties, based on their separate barracks in Kupang, and regional languages in East Timor.
Joao Tavares is the Commander. Eurico Guterres is Deputy Commander.
The former civilian/political arm of the militias still seems to exist. It is Forum Pesatuan Demokrasi dan Keadilan (United Front for Democracy and Justice - FPDK). The head of FPDK is sitll Domingos M.D. Soares, the former District Head of Dili. The spokesperson for FPDK is Basilio Araujo, and it was he who announced the formation and aim of the new National Unity Front.
Who are the troops of this new army - National Unity Front?
a). The old militias.
b). New militia recruits. Many of these are East Timorese forced evacuees, who were then sent to Atambua for training as militias.
c). Possibly ex ABRI (army) personnel.
d). Indonesian mercenaries. Places mentioned in Indonesia as sources for the mercenaries are Jung Pandang (Sulawesi), Bima (Sumbawa - West Nusa Tenggara) and Java, the first two being strongly Islamic areas. A "jihad" has been declared against the UN and presumably against the new East Timorese government. One report states that over 90,000 have signed up for the jihad.
How many FPB troops are there? One report says 56,000.
Who is organising the militias? Clearly the army, almost certainly the two best trained and competent branches of the army, namely Kostrad (Soeharto’s old command) and Kopassus (Soeharto’s son-in-law’s old command). Both American trained. Both have been in East Timor protecting Soeharto’s interests for many years.
Where is the headquarters? It is difficult to be precise. The HQ for the successful deportation exercise was in Atambua (near the border) and clearly this is still the forward military base for training and military operations. In addition the army command for East Timor, namely Korem 164 which was in Dili for over 20 years, is in the process of moving to Maumere (the original plan was Ende) a town of 40,000) on the north coast. Flores is the neighbouring island to Timor and part of the Provinces of East Nusa Tenggara (West Timor, Flores, Sumba). The army command is not being relocated (why relocate?) In Kupang the Provincial capital of 25,000 but in Flores. Thus, possibly the headquarters for the National Unity Front of army and militias will be in Maumere, Atambua and maybe Kupang.
It cannot come through offical army budget, but will no doubt come through a special account controlled by the army. Two sources of funds have been mentioned in Indonesia:
Tutut, Soeharto’s eldest daughter, who has many business interests in East Timor including coffee and marble and sandalwood, has been reported as having given Rp.3000 million to the war chest to fight UN / East Timor. If true, it is logical to assume that other members of the Jakarta elite who have interests in East Timor such as other members of the Cendana family (Soeharto himself, his youngest son Tommy Utomo) also former military commanders (now billionaires from East Timorese concessions and monopolies) such as General Benny Murdani (an unofficial advisor to opposition leader Megawati Sukarnoputri) have also given large sums. ii. Ex-General Prabowo (son-in-law of Soeharto, formerly in Dili and commander of Kopassus) has direct links with Besi Merah Putih (Red and White Iron one of the more vicious of the militias). They trained near Bogor in West Jawa with Prabowo’s money. He also has the loyalty of many current Kopassus (Special Command) leaders, who spearheaded the wave of terror in East Timor since early 1999. Prabowo is a man of enormous wealth and also has excellent connexions with wealthy Moslems overseas (he fled to Jordan to avoid trial in 1998). When he was in charge of Kopassus in 1997, he financed Kopassus’ new weaponry from overseas, without any need to be subject to Indonesian army finances. At the time Kopassus was called ‘an army within the army’, a sort of private army. It would be naive to imagine that Prabowo is not one of the main sponsors of the new war.
4. Presence of militias, and pro-Jakarta forces in Kupang.
iii. Eurico Guterres has rented a house behind the Catholic Cathedral in Kupang.
TNI, POLICE AND MILITIAS - THE DYNAMICS.
1. TNI and Police
2. The Militias
i. The militias are scared of the army. They are becoming more fully the surrogate army for the TNI. The army insisted on the forced evacuations form East Timor, but many of the militias (East Timorese themselves) did not agree, but had to go along with it.
ii. There is speculation in Kupang that Joao Tavares and Eurico Guterres might one day be killed by the army, who will blame the UN forces for doing it. (Guterres himself divulged this when speaking in his mother tongue - Tetum - at one of the camps.)
3. Drugs
Some militias have been using drugs, e.g. Aitarak and Besi Merah Putih (ex-General Prabowo’s group). The drug used is called colloquially "obat anjing gila" - mad dog pills, or rabies pills. Others have not used drugs, eg Halilintar (lightening). This rather points to the possibility that there is a difference between the hard-line militias, who are under the direct control of the army or other members of he Jakarta elite, form whom they obtain drugs, and the softer militias who wanted integration but were less inclined to indulge in drugs and massacres.
4. Probowo v. Wiranto
Two months after Wiranto became the Commander of the Defence Forces and the Minister of Defence in March 1998, he had General Prabowo investigated by a special army tribunal, which found him guilty of improper practices relating to the May riots and April disappearances of students in Jakarta. Prabowo was discharged form the army. There had been enmity between the two men previously, but this exacerbated this personal hostility, so that it has become a permanent feature of the Jakarta elite power play. It is likely that some of the militia activity in East Timor has been influenced by this division, and has led to divided loyalties and the lack of a single command.
Each general has supporters, but it is impossible to call one group hard-line, and the other soft-line. Both are hard-line, and exist for the sake of personal ambition. Prabowo is known for his ruthlessness, and has the support of Major-General Zacky Anwar, who is the architect of the plan implemented in 1998 to set Timorese against Timorese.
THE FUTURE OF EASTERN INDONESIA
1. An undercover plan
i. There is constant talk in Timor and Flores, both of which are parts of NTT Province, of a plan relating to eastern Indonesia. in this regard, eastern Indonesia refers mainly to the provinces of NTT and Maluku (Ambon), but includes parts of other nearby provinces, particularly where there are pockets of Christianity.
2. Destabilisation
i. Indonesia is 85% Moslem, 5% Protestant and 4% Catholic. The Protestants and Catholics enjoy influence in Indonesia far in excess of their numerical strength.
3. Why Destabilisation?
4. Examples of Incidents
MILITARY CRIMES
East Timor September 4-25 September
a. Death and ill-treatment
These events happened as follows:
4. Another report: x saw a 19 year-old girl who had her font burnt from forehead to toes, including her whole face. She was in Kupang, but came form near Ermera (East Timor), here the whole house was burnt and to escape she had to run through the flames. In this incident 6 young children ran form the back of the house and have not been seen again. The girl could not talk because her face was taut with burns. She was in a Catholic clinic in Kupang with her mother and father. There were plans for her to go to Jakarta. A priest in Jakarta is paying.
5. Babies in Becora, Dili, were killed in a number of ways, according to stories of deportees in Kupang: i. Smashed against the wall till they were quivering; ii. Thrown into fires; iii. Piled up in heaps then stabbed with long machete knives. Sometimes these methods were used together. For instance, a baby who was not completely dead because of the stabbing, was then thrown into a fire.
6. Separation of families.
a. There are many stories of deportee families being separated. Most forcefully displaced people are women and children. The men have either gone to the hills, been forced to join the militias or eliminated. This happened at Batugade, near the West Timor - East Timor border, and at Atambua. The men were forced to become militias, to fight against the UN troops, and the women and children were sent on to refugee camps. Children in Kupang tell vivid stories of this separation of their fathers and mothers. Young children are being palmed out for adoption.
b. Looting and destruction
1. Over 100 houses have been burned in the East Timor enclave of Oecusse.
40,000 out of a population of 56,000 have left or been evacuated. 2. Militias stole safes from banks and private houses in East Timor, took them to Kupang and have had them cut open. One car workshop in Kupang apologised (20th September) that they could not do any repairs to customer cars, because they were too busy cutting open large numbers of "army" safes. 3. Both SSpS Sisters and Carmelite Sisters went back from Atambua to Becora (Dili) and Maubara respectively and found their houses wrecked and all possessions taken. This was during 8-18 September. 4. There has been major looting by army and militias. truck loads of TVs, fridges, washing machines, furniture have been arriving from East Timor. A huge number of large trucks have been seen passing villages in West Timor on the way to Kupang. The army has opened a number of stores in Kupang as out-lets selling their war booty. Some have been taken by ferry and land through Flores at night (from Ende to Labuan Bajo and so to Sumbawa, Lombok, Bali, Java).
5. Some UN vehicles have been seen driving around Kupang with groups of Timorese militias inside.
6. At Ermera all medicine were taken by the militias, with one Sister was trying to treat a patient. No medicines were left.
c. Further reports on the genocide.
a. Death and Ill-treatment.
1. Refugee/deportee pregnant mothers form Covalima who were camping on the side of the road in Belu District, West Timor, near a village between Kade and Halilulik, were taken by militias/military in a dawn raid, and had their fonts slit open (from breast to abdomen), while they were still alive. the baby inside was pulled out and thrown away, then the mothers had their throats slit. Some of the headless bodies were then tided up on posts and trees for others to see. (These incidents occurred during the fortnight 4-18 September. They were relatd by a Sister from Belu District, resident in Kupang who got the stories form the many hundreds of refugees/deportees who live in that area.)
2. There is a camp of 5000 Oecusse refugees/deportees at Oelfua, which ison the West Timor side of the East Timor (Oecusse) border. Fr. Andre, the local priest said on 24th September in Kupang (where he had come to collect rice) that 6 men are taken from the camp each night and executed. The method of death is unknown. This is clearly for the sake of intimidation. As this report is being written (25th September) nightly deaths are still occurring. There is no protection, no authority to whom to turn. 3. Soldiers and militias regularly take young girls from the refugee camps for rape.
4. Young men are taken form the camps, then trnsported to Atambua for training to be militias against the UN.
5. People telephone convents in Kupang to ask for refugee children. Two requests were for 4 children each "by later this afternoon". The Sisters made excuses. It is thought that the caller was a middleman (sympathetic to the army) who would then sell the children to army officers or others, and the children would be "adopted" kin Java or elsewhere. This is truly genocide. Past experience of this military practice suggests that these children are often used as servants and then when older thrown out. 6. Army and militia trucks speed along the road form Dili to Kupang, pushing others off the road by their speed, and by using the "klaxon" loud and long. If frustrated, the people in the back start shooting into the air. 7. In one village between Soe and Niki-Niki, one primary school boy going to school was slow in getting off the road. He was hit by the army truck which did not stop. The boy was killed. During 13-19 September.
8. In Kupang at Maulafa, on 20th September an army truck with uniformed soldiers in the back, passed a university student on his motorbike, and pushed him of the road. He was anry so he hit the side of the truck with his hand. Then the army retaliated by chasing him. He rode home but they followed him and informed his parents that they would burn down the house unless they received Rp.500,000 immediately. The parents managed to rustle the money together form neighbours.
9. During the week of 7-15 September militias entered refugee camps and other church places where refugees were. They cam in during day or night, without invitation, or accompaniment by a Sister. They wore plain clothes and looked as if bent on evil. They were looking for wanted people. This activity later stopped. Probably as a result of NTT government pressure. 10. Children sit traumatised inside the church hall at Maria Assumpta Church, Kupang. they will not play outside. One old an came to help with chopping wood for the kitchen saying, "I want to cry but I can’t".
EFFECTS OF EAST TIMOR ISSUE ON LIFE IN WEST TIMOR
c. Homes near some of the refugee/deportee camps in Belu District (West Timor) have been burnt. This is possibly so that there is no fraternisation between refugees and locals, or so that the refugees cannot get food form the locals.
d. There are insufficient supplies in Kefamenanu and Atambua hospitals.
Refugees/Deportees - Location, plight, needs.
Top Priorities
a. Protection, as this report is being written, refugees/deportees are being killed. Thus absolute need for immediate presence of Red Cross, High Commission for Refugees with Peacekeepers in West Timor to arrange a safe corridor for repatriation to East Timor.
b. Supplies (in order of priority) 1. Water and sanitation; 2. Medicines;
3. Non-rice foodstuffs (eg vegetables, fish)
Plight and Needs
a. Protection.
People are still being killed. Those killed are either taken from the camps and killed, or if they are non-camp refugees, are killed wherever they are found. Other people are on the ‘wanted’ list, so are in danger of being killed. Militias are still searching for these people, so they are in a state of great fear. They move around constantly, never staying long in one place.
Two initiatives must be taken as a matter of urgency:
1. The UN must expand its protection to West Timor. they need to negotiate urgently with Indonesia to provide firstly protection and secondly humanitarian relief.
2. Large sums of money are needed to evacuate people to Australia, safer areas of Indonesia and other countries.
b. Water and Sanitation
This is the highest priority, after protection. Disease is likely to spread through the camps very soon. Some camps are in reasonable condition, eg GOR, others are dirty and disease-ridden, eg Noelbaki.
c. Food Relief
1. Refugees/deportees are being kept alive with rice, which generally speaking is supplied by the Red Cross, the local government or the church. The main food is vegetables, for the sake of nutrition. 2. The Indonesian government in Jakarta (Social Department) has promised money which they say is sufficient for 100,000 refugees for 8 weeks. This probably only amounts to the provision of rice, and does not include other foodstuffs or medicines. Clearly this provision is inadequate in every way. 3. Church groups who have fed refugees in Kupang for 2 weeks have received no assistance from the government or Red Cross whatsoever. 4. Where the local government assists the refugees, it is commonly with the produce of local people, collected by the local government. The local government does not always dig into its own pocket. Refugees/deportees are mixed on common sites, pro-integration and pro-independence. This makes people very scared and suspicious they refuse to give their names, in case others hear. It is a continuation of the terror and fear they have experienced for months. GOR (Sports Hall) within the town of Kupang at Oebufu (near bishop’s house). This is the showcase. The people are from Dili. They have been given adequate supplies by the NTT Provincial government, the Red Cross and the Church. this includes food, sleeping gear and cooking utensils. Families cook individually, people can come and go as they wish. Other camps are far worse.
Numbers and locations
1. How many refugees/deportees have come out of East Timor? Probably 250,000. The list below from the local Indonesian government authorities gives 202,000 as the number of refugees as of 22nd September, but later on 24th, this number was increased to 212,000. A. Province of Nusa Tenggara Timur (NTT) which includes West Timor. All the areas mentioned below are "Districts" in the NTT province, except the town of Kupang (administratively equivalent to a district/Kabupaten). The figures are quoted in the local daily "Pos Kupang" (22nd September 1999, p.11) and give their source aas the Local NTT government, Satkorlak PB NTT.
Kupang Town 23,575. Kupang District 35,541. TTS 2,423. TTU 19,818. Belu 115,904.
Other parts of NTT province (mostly in Flores) Alor 2,464. Flores Timur 802. Sikka 358. Manggarai 209. Ngada 170. Total 202,542.
B. Numbers in other parts of Indonesia.
Bali 425 (counted by Catholic Church 20th September)
Other provinces an estimated 10,000. Details below.
2. Names of camps/locations.
There are at least 30 camps in West Timor. In and around Kupang Noelbaki 30 km out of Kupang. Mostly, no all, pro-Jakarta. Naibonat GOR 4,000 showcase camp where visitors are taken.
Carmelite Monastery 101. RVM convent Walikota 463. Fed twice a day because the people will not split into groups to cook through fear. RVM convent Oelnasi about 50. PRR convent 50. SVD house none.
Atambua area
Atapupu Paroki Sadi (many sick) Haliwen (many sick) Salore, Silawan, Aula SVD Nenuk around 1,000 - eat alone not with the community. Nela Parish.
Note: from Halilulik to Betun the road is full of refugees and camps (official and unofficial). From Atapupu to the East Timor - West Timor border the roadside is full of refugee camps.
Central West Timor: SoE - stadium. Naen 8,000 ex-Oecusse. Oelfua 5,000 ex-Oecusse.
Resettlement from West Timor to other provinces.
A. This was to have occurred 10 days after arrival in West Timor. B. NTT government plans exist - copies have been sighted which state that 125,000 people will return to East Timor and that 125,000 will be resettled in other parts of NTT. The map shows where the new resettlement sites are throughout the 12 Districts of NTT. Total 250,000. Clearly this is a plan from before the deportation started.
C. It is not known if this plan will be (fully) implemented. First, it is possible that the 125,000 returnees will not be allowed, or able, to return. They are hostages to developments in East Timor. secondly, thee is evidence which indicates that plans are in place to evacuate refugees currently in West Timor, not to other parts of NTT but to other parts of Indonesia. see below.
Known destinations of refugees/deportees according to pictures on Indonesian TV and in newspapers.
1. Ujung Pandang (Sulawesi). 2. Surabaya (Java). Yogyakarta (Java). 4.
Jakarta. 5. Bali. 6. Kalimantan. 7. Irian Jaya.
A visit to the Transmigration Training Centre, Kupang on 24th September revealed that two East Timorese groups had left that day by boat for two different destinations - Kalimantan and Irian Jaya. Whilst at the Transmigration Training Centre, another bus was just pulling out with "Transmigration Group" written on the front, and about 30 passengers inside. The whole of the parking area in front of the Training Centre was filled with personal belongs and large bales of goods, wrapped in sacking. They looked like official transmigration stores.
Life in another province.
Life for refugees has never been easy. These are some of the problems:
1. The transmigrants do not know the local language, and the locals do not know theirs.
2. They are often made to feel like outsiders.
3. The locals sometimes resent the transmigrants taking their land.
4. The transmigrants do not understand the system of farming in the new area.
5. The seasons may well differ.
6. They do not get the support promised by the government.
7. The farming land is barren, and needs to be cleared of rocks or jungle. 8. The transmigrants may be stigmatised for being responsible for the loss of East Timor to Indonesia.
9. They will forever be Indonesians and never again regarded as East Timorese.
10. They will lose their Timorese culture.
11. They may never again return to East Timor.
Repatriation to East Timor
C. Indonesia will be able to argue that these people are willing transmigrants, and are no longer refugees. The refugees will have forfeited their chance of repatriation, and the Un will have no right to investigate their whereabouts, or give them humanitarian assistance.
D. It is naive to imagine that many of the East Timorese refugees/deportees will return to East Timor.
From:
Commissio de Iustitia, Pace et Creationis Integritate
Unionum Superiorum Generalium USG/UISG